Google drafted state chatbot safety bills that exempt its own Gemini
State capitals spent 2026 passing laws about chatbots and children. An NPR investigation says one of the biggest chatbot makers helped write the language — and the language has holes in it.
Google helped draft and lobby for chatbot-safety bills in at least ten states this year, and several of those bills contain carve-outs that could exempt the company's own Gemini from the rules, according to an NPR investigation by Katie McQue. The pattern is unusual for its simultaneity: identical or near-identical exemption language appeared across statehouses in a single legislative session rather than spreading over the years it normally takes model bills to travel. In Colorado, the Chatbot Safety Act that Governor Jared Polis signed in May 2026 contains twelve categories of carve-out — developer tools, video games, voice assistants, and chatbots built into social platforms — and sponsor state Rep. Sean Camacho acknowledged he was asked by the governor's office to make the bill look like versions introduced elsewhere. One Republican lawmaker told NPR a Google lobbyist asked them to sponsor the bill; they declined.
The exemptions are specific enough to matter. An exemption for "a feature within another software application, web interface, or computer program" appears in bills in at least eight states, including Idaho, Nebraska, New Jersey and Oklahoma; policy analysts say it could cover Meta AI and Grok, both embedded in larger platforms. Five states exempt any chatbot that "functions as a speaker and voice command interface or voice-activated virtual assistant," which describes Alexa. Several bills limit their minor-safety duties to an "account holder" who is a minor, a definition that does not reach free users who never register — and Tech Oversight Project's Marjorie Connolly argues ChatGPT, Copilot and Claude could claim they were marketed primarily to developers, while Gemini could sit behind the search-engine exemption. Hawaii state Rep. Trish La Chica says lobbyists brought her a Google-authored framework early in the session; she declined to sponsor it, and the bill that became Act 248 had the exemptions stripped before signing. Arizona's governor vetoed hers in June. Idaho, Georgia, Iowa, Washington, Nebraska and Oregon enacted theirs. Lobbying disclosures show Google registered in support of chatbot bills in Iowa, Colorado, Nebraska and Arizona; Google told NPR it collaborates with lawmakers to shape "thoughtful, effective" AI legislation.
Why it matters: the vaguest clause is the one that decides enforcement. Colorado requires companies to "institute technically feasible measures" against sexual content and simulated emotional dependence — and the company decides what is technically feasible. Attorney Laura Marquez-Garrett of the Social Media Victims Law Center calls that a massive exception with no equivalent elsewhere in law. Cynthia Montoya, whose 13-year-old daughter Juliana died by suicide after chatbot interactions, testified against the bill and says a weak law is worse than none because lawmakers will treat chatbot regulation as settled. This is the same dynamic we flagged when OpenAI said US AI policy is being written in state capitals — except the drafting pen turns out to belong to the industry being regulated.
ByteDance's Jianying launched an AI production suite and folded AI credits into a single subscription called AI Ultra. The China version of CapCut announced a one-stop workbench, Jianying Hub, that pairs an infinite canvas with a multi-track editor so a creator can go from one sentence, a reference video or a document to a script, then generate images, video and audio through ByteDance's Jimeng and Xiaoyunque platforms before finishing on the timeline. A companion editing agent handles asset sorting, filler-word cuts, subtitle correction and packaging, and accepts custom Skills; on mobile it ships as "Xiaoying," which doubles as a marketing assistant for merchants. The company says 67.68 million users exported their first project through Jianying in the past year, 3.26 million Douyin creators with 10,000-plus followers edit with it, and it serves 1.66 million small merchants — a reach number, not a benchmark, but it is why the subscription matters more than the feature list.
What to watch: whether the Colorado rules survive the pre-rulemaking comment period without the carve-outs being narrowed, and whether Google's model language shows up in states that convene in 2027.
Should states accept model legislation written by the companies it regulates? Tell us in the comments.
Sources: NPR · Techmeme · Transformer · Colorado General Assembly, HB26-1263 · 雷峰网 Leiphone · 鞭牛士 Bianews · 剪映 (CapCut China)
